Skip to content
  • About
    • Explore AFTE
    • Board of Directors
    • News & Events
    • Contact AFTE
  • The John Wesley Fellowship
    • About the Fellowship
    • Directory of Fellows
    • Featured Fellows
    • Sample Publications by Fellows
    • Fellowship Podcasts
  • Opportunities
    • John Wesley Fellowship Application
    • International Teaching Teams and Collaborative Research Project
    • Collaborative Research Project Application
    • International Teaching Teams Application
  • Resources
    • Catalyst Publications
    • Catalyst Publications by Category
    • Photo Library
    • Videos
  • Kingdom Building
    • Give
    • Prayer
  • About
    • Explore AFTE
    • Board of Directors
    • News & Events
    • Contact AFTE
  • The John Wesley Fellowship
    • About the Fellowship
    • Directory of Fellows
    • Featured Fellows
    • Sample Publications by Fellows
    • Fellowship Podcasts
  • Opportunities
    • John Wesley Fellowship Application
    • International Teaching Teams and Collaborative Research Project
    • Collaborative Research Project Application
    • International Teaching Teams Application
  • Resources
    • Catalyst Publications
    • Catalyst Publications by Category
    • Photo Library
    • Videos
  • Kingdom Building
    • Give
    • Prayer
  • About
    • Explore AFTE
    • Board of Directors
    • News & Events
    • Contact AFTE
  • The John Wesley Fellowship
    • About the Fellowship
    • Directory of Fellows
    • Featured Fellows
    • Sample Publications by Fellows
    • Fellowship Podcasts
  • Opportunities
    • John Wesley Fellowship Application
    • International Teaching Teams and Collaborative Research Project
    • Collaborative Research Project Application
    • International Teaching Teams Application
  • Resources
    • Catalyst Publications
    • Catalyst Publications by Category
    • Photo Library
    • Videos
  • Kingdom Building
    • Give
    • Prayer
  • About
    • Explore AFTE
    • Board of Directors
    • News & Events
    • Contact AFTE
  • The John Wesley Fellowship
    • About the Fellowship
    • Directory of Fellows
    • Featured Fellows
    • Sample Publications by Fellows
    • Fellowship Podcasts
  • Opportunities
    • John Wesley Fellowship Application
    • International Teaching Teams and Collaborative Research Project
    • Collaborative Research Project Application
    • International Teaching Teams Application
  • Resources
    • Catalyst Publications
    • Catalyst Publications by Category
    • Photo Library
    • Videos
  • Kingdom Building
    • Give
    • Prayer
  • Home
  • >
  • Footnotes
  • >
  • Calvin versus Wesley?

More Articles

Loading...
Our King Carries a Towel, Not a Scepter
The world watched last September as millions mourned the death of Queen Elizabeth. Subsequently, many watched with great interest as Charles was enthroned as...
August 18, 2023

Author:

  • Rob Haynes
Our Postmodern Moment, Part 3: The Biblical Metanarrative
This is the final installment of a three-part article that I’ve been invited to write on the question of how Christians might engage our...
Perspectives
/
August 9, 2023

Author:

  • J. Richard Middleton
Jesus: Not Superhero but Friend
I preached recently and was given the Easter Emmaus text (Luke 24:13–35), a story I have never really found interesting. Having to say something...
Conversations
/
August 7, 2023

Author:

  • Samantha L. Miller
An Education or a Diploma?
Are you seeking a diploma, or are you seeking an education? So many of you tell me you’re here because graduating from here will...
Conversations
/
June 5, 2023

Author:

  • Samantha L. Miller
On Reading a Book’s Cover
Living in the age of TikTok, sound bytes, emojis, and GIFs one might think the practice of reading a book is antiquated and unnecessary....
Conversations
/
May 29, 2023

Author:

  • Tammie Grimm
Our Postmodern Moment, Part 2: The Biblical Metanarrative
This is part 2 of a three-part essay in which I’ve been invited to revisit the analysis that Brian Walsh and I made in...
Perspectives
/
May 24, 2023

Author:

  • J. Richard Middleton

Calvin versus Wesley?

Footnotes
/
October 23, 2013

Don Thorsen is a Wesleyan, and there's never any doubt about where his allegiances lie in his new book, Calvin vs. Wesley: Bringing Belief in Line with Practice (Nashville: Abingdon, 2013). From the first page to the last, though, his tone is irenic and he approaches his task with admirable humility and graciousness. He doesn't favor Wesley by bashing Calvin, but rather allows them their own voices while demonstrating their significant points of agreement and crucial areas of difference. The result is a useful, non-technical study suitable for anyone with questions about the relationship between these two venerable traditions, or who wonders about such contemporary theological fault lines as predestination, free will, or the authority of Scripture.

The easiest way to summarize Thorsen's presentation is to refer to the contrast he develops between Calvinism and Wesleyanism:

  • Calvinism emphasizes Total Depravity, whereas Wesleyanism emphasizes that All are sinful.
  • Calvinism emphasizes Unconditional election, whereas Wesleyanism emphasizes Conditional election.
  • Calvinism emphasizes Limited atonement, whereas Wesleyanism emphasizes Unlimited atonement.
  • Calvinism emphasizes Irresistable grace, whereas Wesleyanism emphasizes Resistable grace.
  • Calvinism emphasizes Perseverance of the saints, whereas Wesleyanism emphasizes Assurance of salvation.
Thorsen CalvinWesley13
Don Thorsen, Calvin vs. Wesley (Abingdon, 2013)

Drawing attention to the highlighted letters in each description, Thorsen thus represents the acronym associated with Calvin, TULIP, and introduces a companion acronym for Wesley, ACURA.

Focusing on these differences, we might easily overlook the degree to which Thorsen finds common ground between Wesley and Calvin. As his chapter titles suggest, what typically separates them are questions of emphasis and nuance. Of course, matters of emphasis are often critical for the one tradition or the other, but our recognition of Wesley's attention, say, to God's grace should not mask the reality that Calvin likewise emphasized God's grace. This is true even if they understood grace differently, a difference Thorsen captures in his chapter title "Grace: More Prevenient Than Irresistable." Whereas Calvin took divine grace to be effectual ("that is, people cannot resist God's work in their lives for their justification, sanctification, and glorification"), Wesley spoke of "prevenient grace," which "enables people freedom to choose justification, sanctification, and other matters in life" (122).

Thorsen reflects similarly on a range of theological loci: the nature of God, the role of Scripture, portraits of humanity, the meaning of salvation, the character of spirituality, the nature of the church, and the character of ministry. Although he devotes significant attention to articulating Calvin's and Wesley's views on these matters, and to comparing their thought on each point, the overall thesis of the book presses for a decision in favor of Wesley. This is due in part to his claim that many Christians who claim to follow Calvin actually live out a Wesleyan faith. It's also due to the care with which Thorsen shows the biblical character and practical vitality of Wesley's thought.

Calvin vs. Wesley is a timely book that deserves a wide readership. It brings its readers into conversation with Calvin's and Wesley's writings (rather than the writings of today's Calvinists, Calvinians, and Wesleyans). It provides Wesleyans with solid instruction in their own evangelical faith. And it does both in a conversational tone that's easy to read. Discussion questions at the end of each chapter make the book even more useful for teachers and students.

About the Author

  • Joel B. Green

    Joel B. Green

    Green is a John Wesley Fellow and elder in The United Methodist Church. He is professor of New Testament interpretation and Associate Dean for the Center for Advanced Theological Studies, Fuller Theological Seminary. He has authored or edited more than 50 books, including Conversion in Luke-Acts: Divine Initiative, Human Cognition, and the People of God (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2015), Why Salvation? (Abingdon, 2013), and The World of the New Testament: Cultural, Social, and Historical Contexts (with Lee Martin McDonald; Baker Academic, 2013).

About AFTE

  • About Foundation
  • About The Fellowship
  • Board of Directors
  • Featured Fellows
  • Directory of Fellows

Publications

  • Publications by Fellows
  • Podcast
  • Recent Publications
  • News & Events

Participate

  • Give
  • Apply for Fellowship
  • Contact Us
Facebook Youtube
  • © 2020 A Foundation for Theological Education
  • Developed & Managed by Tiny Giant